Do Not Sell My Personal Information 
Crystal Palace: Fans call for Martin Kelly over James Tomkins
Many Palace fans on Twitter have called for the return of Martin Kelly after suggesting that he is better than James Tomkins.
James Tomkins or Martin Kelly?
James Tomkins
Martin Kelly
Crystal Palace fan account @JontyCPFC tweeted his opinion that Kelly was better than Tomkins immediately after the Eagles slumped to a 2-0 defeat at home to Leicester before many other fans responded saying that they also agree.
James Tomkins played the full 90 minutes and wasn’t able to prevent keeping Leicester out; Martin Kelly had to spend the match watching from the bench.
While Tomkins featured far more often last season (with 29 games to Martin Kelly’s 13, per WhoScored), injuries have meant that Kelly has played more this campaign – and WhoScored’s algorithm suggests that fans are right to be missing the former Liverpool player.
According to their match rating system, Kelly has been the best out of all of Palace’s centre-halves this season, having a healthy average rating of 6.82/10 from six matches. Tomkins, on the other hand, has just a 6.2/10 from his three games played.
Here are some of the fans’ responses below…
100%, Kelly compliments Cahill so much better
— JayJay Rodrigues (@RodriguesJayJay) November 3, 2019
Agreed, Tomkins doesn’t seem anywhere near full sharpness. Kelly for me
— Mark Jones (@MDJones82) November 3, 2019
Obviously
— Guy (@_GuyCPFC) November 4, 2019
I think it’s a case that we have 2 completely different partnerships. Tomkins is best with Mama and Kelly is best with Cahill
— Luke (@lukazmitch) November 4, 2019
Ur just right
— Kev (@kevinbartleyy) November 3, 2019
No brainier for me. Wolverine has been poor tbh.
— CPFCPETE1905 (@cpfcpete1905) November 4, 2019
Tomkins has cost us two goals in two games, kelly is far the better player
— Kev (@kevinbartleyy) November 3, 2019
