Skip to content
Transfer News

The Transfer Tavern

Football transfer news, live rumours, confirmed deals, and inside gossip from the Premier League, La Liga, Serie A, and beyond.

Primary Menu
  • Transfer Rumours
  • Premier League
  • Stadium Guides
Live
  • Home
  • Premier League
  • Everton
  • The Elland Road Player Ratings
  • Everton

The Elland Road Player Ratings

John Edwards 27 September 2012, 9:53 3 minutes read

A disappointing performance from Everton saw Leeds dump them out the Capitol One Cup with a 2-1 victory at Elland Road. It was a lack-lustre display from David Moyes’ side but Leeds deserve credit for a fine performance. Neil Warnock got the tactics spot as El-Hadji Diouf caused the Blues defence all kinds of problems.

But for Moyes the most disappointing aspect of the performance was the manner in which a hardworking Leeds side outfought their Premier League opposition.

On a night Everton fans will want to forget, we take a look at how their players performed.

Jan Mucha- 5

  • Was offered little protection by a poor defence. However, did nothing to convince he should be anything other than a back up to Tim Howard

Seamus Coleman- 4

  • Struggled to contain the threat of El Hadji Diouf which prevented him from getting forward as much as he would have liked. Proved he still has much to learn about the defensive side of the game.

Johnny Heitinga- 3

  • Did nothing to prove why he should be in the side. A very disappointing performance from the Dutchman in a game he should have dominated.

Sylvain Distin- 5

  • Nearly sparked a comeback but will be judged on his defensive display. Was not the worst but you would still expect better from the Frenchman.

Bryan Oveido- 5

  • Was a chance for the new signing to show what he could do but did little to impress. Everton fans will hope there is more to come from him.

Magye Gueye- 4

  • Was very poor in the first half and failed to cause the Leeds defence any problems. Against Championship opposition it was a chance for his to shine and this performance perhaps confirmed he is not cut out for the top level.

Marouane Fellaini- 5

  • Having been so influential in the Premier League the Toffees talisman failed to have the same effect in a more defensive position in the first half. Improved as he pushed further forward in the second half.

Francisco Junior- 3

  • A tough debut for the young midfielder. Struggled to adapt to the pace and physicality and was outplayed by Michael Brown.

Steven Naismith- 3

  • A shocking performance from the former Rangers man. Ineffectual throughout and missed an absolute sitter in the first half.

Kevin Mirallas- 5 

  • Had very little service and struggled stamp his mark on the game. But, for a player of his calibre Everton would have hoped he could have inspired the side a little more with his penchant for the spectacular.

Victor Anichebe- 6

  • Like his strike partner had to rely on scraps due to the lack of service. Despite that his work rate could not be faulted on a frustrating evening.

About the Author

John Edwards

Subscriber

I'm an aspiring sports journalist and I've just graduated from the University of Central Lancashire in Sports Journalism. I've been on placement at Accrington Stanley and Everton. Check out my blog http://www.playingthegame.org/

Visit Website View All Posts

What do you feel about this?

  • Everton

Post navigation

Previous: Rooney, Beckham, Carragher, Gerrard & Cahill Facing HMRC Nightmare?
Next: Desperate Publicity Stunt Or Genuine Act Of Contrition?

Related Stories

ARCH783428_00352110
3 minutes read
  • Everton

Everton make a move for “unbelievable” £50m ace

Rebekka Arnold 26 June 2026, 8:25
3 minutes read
  • Everton

Everton “approach” rejected for “magical” PL ace

Rebekka Arnold 2 February 2026, 10:48
Footballers on bench in coats.
2 minutes read
  • Everton

Manchester United ready to move for “assured” England international to replace Harry Maguire

Barnaby Lane 28 September 2025, 15:58
Manchester City's Nathan Ake. (REUTERS/Molly Darlington)
3 minutes read
  • Everton

Everton plot move for “incredible” £35m PL star

Rebekka Arnold 22 August 2025, 11:46
Neil El Aynaoui. (REUTERS/Pascal Rossignol)
2 minutes read
  • Everton

Everton launch enquiry to battle fellow Friedkin Group club for “versatile” Ligue 1 midfielder

Barnaby Lane 14 July 2025, 16:11
England's Kyle Walker, Bukayo Saka and Eberechi Eze. (REUTERS/Paul Childs)
2 minutes read
  • Everton

Everton agree terms with “unique” England international

Barnaby Lane 17 June 2025, 14:30

Trending Now

West Ham ‘send inquiry’ to sign 39-year-old free agent fwuQPAXXHh0C 1

West Ham ‘send inquiry’ to sign 39-year-old free agent

18 August 2026, 12:27 0
Manchester City told they must pay £120 million to sign “fantastic” World cup star WmOB1GNTJR4L 2

Manchester City told they must pay £120 million to sign “fantastic” World cup star

18 August 2026, 12:08 0
Tottenham Hotspur ‘make approach’ for £100 million-rated Chelsea forward neimLXqXpLzY 3

Tottenham Hotspur ‘make approach’ for £100 million-rated Chelsea forward

18 August 2026, 11:25 0
Champions League club ‘prepared to double’ wages of “outstanding” Manchester United star to lure him away from Old Trafford neimM6siaOam 4

Champions League club ‘prepared to double’ wages of “outstanding” Manchester United star to lure him away from Old Trafford

18 August 2026, 10:44 0
Copyright © 2026 All rights reserved.